Management of
hypothyroidism in Ayurveda
Thyroid gland is one of the most important
and sensitive endocrine gland. As it easily responds to stress and
stimuli the global incidence of hypothyroidism is increasing day by
day. The major function of thyroid
gland is to control the rate of metabolism. The principle function of
thyroxine is to act as a catalyst –of the nature of a ‘’spark’’ for
the maintenance of oxidative metabolism in most tissues. Cells in the
body take their "cue" from thyroxine. The amount of stimulation the
cells receive from thyroxine will determine how "quickly" they perform
their functions1. These functions similar with the
description of agni “angati vyapnoti iti va agnihi” and “agnyate
mreeyate iti va agnihi”.
Hypothyroidism results from inadequate
production of thyroid hormone. Any structural or functional
defects of thyroid gland that significantly impairs its output of
hormones will lead to the hypo metabolic state of hypothyroidism2.
The symptoms of hypothyroidism are notorious
for their nonspecific nature and for the way in which they mimic many
symptoms of other diseases. So it often remains undiagnosed or
misdiagnosed. Vertigo, weight gain, mood disturbances, easy
fatigability, tiredness, lethargy, slowness of memory, intellect and
thought, menstrual irregularities, cold intolerance, dry rough skin,
thin brittle hair, hair fall, Muscle
stiffness, aching, myalgias, cramps, weakness and fatigue, myxedema,
constipation, hoarseness of voice, goiter etc.3
Galaganda
There is no direct mention of thyroid gland in ayurveda. But a disease
by the name galaganda is mentioned in samhitas. The earliest
description of neck swelling is found in atharva veda by the name
apachi. Charaka first described about the disease under the 20
varieties of sleshma vikaras10. Susutha has described that
out of seven layers of the skin, the sixth layer Rohini is galaganda
rogadhistana (Su.Sa.4/4). In nidana sthana he described galaganda as
two encapsulated small or big swellings in the anterior angle of the
neck, which hang like scrotum11 (Su.Ni.11),
whereas charaka mentioned galaganda as solitary swelling
(Ch.Ch.11).
The etiological factors in galaganda include climatic
conditions, water supply, dietary conditions and other surroundings
etc. Susrutha stated that rivers
flowing towards east might give rise to the occurrence of
galaganda11. Bhela described that sleepda and
galaganda are more common in prachya desa (eastern part) of
the country12, and the
persons consuming predominantly fish are liable to develop galgaganda.
Harita samhitakara described the role of dustambu and krimi
dosha in the precipitation of Galaganda.
Kashyapa samhitakara13added
that any part of the country which is cold, damp, with densely
grown long trees, water stagnation and heavy rains may be prone for
the development of Galaganda.
From the
above descriptions Galaganda can be correlated with goiter or some
tumour pathology, where thyroid functions may or may not be affected.
But hypothyroidism is not just a localized disease. It has many
symptoms related to many systems of the body. So it is better not to
restrict hypothyroidism with galaganda.
Management of hypothyroidism
As mentioned by charaka10
“vikaranamakusalo…”exact nomenclature is not necessary for all the
diseases. It insists on diagnosis of constitutional status of the
disease.
As per the nidana Hypothyroidism can be classified
as 1.Primary (thyroid failure)
2. Secondary, (due to pituitary TSH deficit). And 3.
Tertiary (due to hypothalamic deficiency of TRH), the later two
are rare and may not be amicable to ayurvedic treatments.
If hypothyroidism results due to
Genetical and hereditary defects,
these comes under adibala pravritta vyadhis and these are asadhya.
If hypothyroidism results due to Congenital defects
like thyroid gland agenesis, dysgenesis, ectopic thyroid gland comes
under Janmabala pravritta vyadhis. These are preventable if proper
pathyapathya is followed during pregnancy.
The main cause of hypothyroidism is iodine
deficiency, as per sarvadha sarva bahvanam-iodine containing
drugs like shigru, jalakumbhi are advised here.
Another main cause autoimmune
thyroid disease is characterized by gradual lymphatic infiltration and
progressive destruction of the functional thyroid tissue. So it may
be Yapya, means that the treatment should be continued
Jeevanaparvantam with immuno modulatory drugs.
Selection of drugs acting at various
levels
1. At
hypothalamo pituitary level: anti stress drugs, medhya rasayana drugs,
nasya karma may be beneficial.
-
At thyroid gland level: thyroid
stimulatory drugs are recommended here.
-
At metabolism level: deepana,
pacahana, ushna, teekshna, sukshma, lekhana drugs which pep-up body
metabolism is recommended.
-
Immuno-modulatory drugs for
autoimmune related hypothyroidism.
As
the symptoms of hypothyroidsm are notorious, the symptomatic
treatment is followed according to the suitabily of the individual
cases, i.e., sthoulya, sodha etc.
The recent
research work done by Dr. Tripathi and others. Animal studies have
revealed that guggul supports healthy thyroid function, mostly
by increasing the conversion of less active Thyroxin (T4) to
more active Triiodotyronine (T3) through increasing thyroid
proteolytic activity and the uptake of iodine into thyroxin, and
without increasing the production of Thyroid Stimulating Hormone.
Selenium is required for a number of enzymes known as selenoproteins.
The chemical reaction, which converts thyroid hormone T4 into T3, is
catalyzed by specific selenoproteins. Selenium deficiency can impair
thyroid function. The drug pippali increases the absroption of
selinium and this may be cause
for the effectiveness of vardhamana pipppli in hypothyroid
conditions.
The patient who has complications like heart
diseases like bradycardia and cardiomagaly, myxedema coma, are
Pratyakhyeya indicates Achikitsavastha of Vyadhi.
The present
trial drug kanchanara guggulu (Sa. Sam), is found in usage for many
years for Gandhamala, Apache, Arbuda, Grandhi, Kushta, etc, has
been selected to evaluate the efficacy of this drug in
hypothyroidism. Its main ingredients kanchanara, varuna, triphala,
trikatu, trijataka may also useful in hypothyroidism.
Shigru is a
well-known plant in India. It is rich in iodine, which
is an essential component of
thyroid hormones, T3 and T4.
It has deepana, pacahna,
kapha vata hara properties. It is recommended in galaganda, kandu,
sotha, apachi, vrana, medoroga, vidradhi, gulma etc.is selected as
anupana along with KNG.
It
appears to provide it with the
nutrition and substitutes the Iodine, thyroid gland require. Hence the
drug is selected for the study.
The main aim of the study is
1. To
normalize the levels of TSH in the fresh cases.
2. To
maintain the TSH levels in the patients who are already using the
allopathic drug thyronorm and gradually replacing the allopathic drug
with the trail drug.
For fresh
cases the trial drug started immediately after the diagnosis
confirmed.
For the
patients who are already using thyronorm/ eltroxin they were advised
to withdraw the 25 mcg of the drug before starting the trail drug. The
patients were observed carefully for 1 month, if they are comfortable
with the drug and dosage and TSH levels are maintained well they are
advised to withdraw another 25mcg. This way the drug will be totally
replaced with the trail drug.
The trail was
conducted on 32 patients from the Govt Ayurvedic Hospital, Erragadda;
the progress of the patient is observed and recorded. Analysis was
made to assess the results in relation to various factors. 32 patients
were included and examined thoroughly examined and the
Diagnosis of hypothyroidism is based on a
person's medical history, a physical examination, and blood tests. Of
the blood tests for hypothyroidism, the TSH is the most sensitive test14.
As Hypothyroidism doesn’t have any
characteristic symptoms, the following most common symptoms were
carefully screened15.
Inclusion criteria:
Weight gain/unable to loss
weight Vertigo
Easy
fatigability
Lethargy
Cold intolerance
Hair
loss
Slowness of memory, intellect and
thought Anorexia
Constipation
Gaseous distention
Hoarseness/slowness of
voice Menstrual
irregularities
Oligomenorrhoea
/Amenorrhea
Parasthesias
Muscle cramps and
weakness Muscle
stiffness and aching
Dry
skin
Coarse, brittle, dull hair
Puffiness of the face, hands,
feet slow reflexes
Goiter
Exclusion criteria:
1.
Patients with Cardiomegaly and
Bradycardia.
2.
Patients who are above 65 yrs and
using the allopathic drug thyronorm.
3.
Patients who are suffering from hypothyroidism for more than 10 years.
2. DRUGS
-
KANCHANARA GUGGULU5,7,8
( Sa. Sam )
The drug Kanchanara guggulu a compound
Ayurvedic preparation consists of Guggulu, Kanchanara, Varuna,
Triphala, Trikatu and Trijataka (preparation of the drug mentioned in
drug aspect). It is one of the safest and the very useful drug in
ayurveda, is found in usage for many years for gandhamala, apachi,
Arbuda, Granthi, Vrana, Gulma, Kusta, Bhagandara etc. In the present
study KNG is evaluated for thyroid stimulating activity.
-
SHIGRU PATRA KWATHA6,7:
Shigru is a
well-known plant in India. It has deepana, pachana, kapha vata hara
properties. It is recommended in galaganda, kandu, sotha, apachi,
vrana, medoroga, vidradhi, gulma etc. As it is rich in iodine, which
is the main cause for hypothyroidism, is selected as anupana along
with KNG.
Shigru
leaves are dried and the powder was given to the patients and advised
them to make decoction.
Kwatha preparation: To the coarse
powder of one part of drug, add 8 parts of water, boil and reduce them
to 1/4th and filter it.
THE
METHODOLOGY:
The aim of the study of the study:
1.
Normalize the levels of TSH in the fresh cases.
2.
To maintain the TSH levels in the patients who are already
using the allopathic drug thyronorm and gradually replacing the
allopathic drug with the trail drug
Type of trial:
Open trail
Mode of administration:
Oral
Method of administration:
1.
For fresh cases started immediately after the diagnosis
confirmed.
2.
For the patients who are already using thyronorm advised
withdraw the 25 mcg of the drug before starting the rail drug.
3.
The patients were observed carefully for 1 month, if they are
comfortable with the drug and dosage and TSH levels are maintained
well they are advised to withdraw another 25mcg. This way the drug is
totally replaced with the trail drug.
Dose of the drug:
i) Kanchanara guggulu 250mg b.d.
ii)
Shigru patra kwatha 250ml b.d
Period of study: 3 months
Patients were advised not to take
Kapha and Medo vardhaka Ahara and Vihara’s like diwaswapna, madhura
guru dravya sevana etc.
CLINICAL ASSESSMENT:
The progress
of the patient is observed and recorded after every 15 days. This
procedure is followed for duration of 90 days. After the completion
of the duration the results are assessed basing on observations. The
results are assessed in terms of complete relief, marked, moderate and
mild relief and no relief.
1.
Complete relief: TSH levels normalized and 100% symptoms
relieved.
2.
Marked relief: TSH levels normalized and symptomatic relief up
to 75%.
3.
Moderate relief: TSH levels normalized and symptomatic relief
up to 50-75%.
4.
Mild relief: TSH levels normalized and symptomatic relief up to
25-50%.
5.
No relief: no change in the TSH levels and no symptomatic
relief.
32 patients were
recruited in the study and the assessment was done for every 15days.Of
the 32 patients 16 patients were fresh cases and 16 patients are
already using the modern medicine eltroxin. The results of the
patients who completed the treatment of 90days were analyzed.
In the 16 fresh
cases the TSH levels came to normal range after the completion of the
treatment. The 16 who are already using allopathic medicine were
gradually replaced with the trial drug and the TSH levels were in
normal range as summarized in table 5.11 and 5.12.
Table 5.11 showing the levels of
TSH before and after treatment:
|
S.no |
O.P.NO. |
Before treatment |
After treatment |
|
TSH (mU/L) |
TSH (mU/L) |
|
1 |
16884 |
9.66 |
3.93 |
|
2 |
22490 |
>100 |
3.29 |
|
3 |
5869 |
99.21 |
0.32 |
|
4 |
7289 |
11.13 |
0.01 |
|
5 |
11960 |
25.99 |
6.67 |
|
6 |
12460 |
116.6 |
1.09 |
|
7 |
6430 |
6.68 |
2.08 |
|
8 |
5892 |
10.73 |
3.56 |
|
9 |
6478 |
12.97 |
3.22 |
|
10 |
12926 |
22.38 |
0.90 |
|
11 |
11872 |
10.38 |
0.04 |
|
12 |
13482 |
48.72 |
1.47 |
|
13 |
5340 |
10.67 |
1.21 |
|
14 |
1792 |
11.32 |
3.54 |
|
15 |
8762 |
10.12 |
2.29 |
|
16 |
7280 |
100 |
5.89 |
For the
patients who are already using thyronorm advised withdraw the 25 mcg
of the drug before starting the trail drug. The patients were observed
carefully for I month, if they are comfortable with the drug and
dosage and TSH levels are maintained well they are advised to withdraw
another 25mcg and the drug was totally replaced with
Trial drug.
|
S.no |
O.P.No. |
Duration |
Dosage of thyronorm |
Before treatment |
After treatment |
|
TSH (mU/L) |
TSH (mU/L) |
|
1. |
2970 |
5yrs |
50mcg |
5.66 |
4.56 |
|
2. |
5290 |
8yrs |
75mcg |
0.90 |
1.25 |
|
3. |
3472 |
8mon |
25mcg |
1.47 |
1.81 |
|
4. |
8960 |
2yrs |
50mcg |
2.27 |
3.46 |
|
5. |
5269 |
5mon |
25mcg |
3.22 |
3.67 |
|
6. |
6840 |
2yrs |
100mcg |
2.07 |
1.90 |
|
7. |
10964 |
4mon |
25mcg |
4.12 |
3.54 |
|
8. |
4263 |
6yrs |
25mcg |
4.12 |
3.57 |
|
9. |
3940 |
7mon |
50mcg |
3.8 |
5.07 |
|
10. |
10164 |
1yr |
75mcg |
2.68 |
1.21 |
|
11. |
4170 |
21/2yr |
50mcg |
3.44 |
5.12 |
|
12. |
3680 |
1yr |
25mcg |
1.11 |
1.80 |
|
13. |
2865 |
1mon |
25mcg |
6.84 |
4.79 |
|
14. |
6430 |
2yrs |
75mcg |
5.54 |
3.68 |
|
15. |
10890 |
3yrs |
25mcg |
1.77 |
2.34 |
|
16. |
5128 |
8yrs |
50mcg |
4.74 |
3.21 |
Table 5.12 showing
the levels of TSH before and after the treatment in chronic cases.
|